If you’ve got 90 minutes to spare and love The New Yorker, especially its iconic cartoons, you won’t want to miss Very Semi-Serious…A Partially Thorough Portrait of New Yorker Cartoonists. The documentary, directed by Leah Wolchok and produced by Davina Pardo, debuts on HBO tonight, Monday, December 14, 2015, 9:00 – 10:30 p.m. ET/PT. (Check listings for additional HBO playdates in the weeks ahead and availability on HBO NOW, HBO GO and HBO On Demand.)
Yes, Very Semi-Serious is long and has an equally long-winded title…both of which (the length and the title) could use some tweaking. But the film’s primary goal–to provide a “partially thorough portrait”of the cartoonists who continue to submit their work to the venerable 90-year-old magazine–is more than adequately realized.
The film zeroes in on the magazine’s weekly rigorous cartoon selection process–approximately 15 cartoons out of thousands of submissions are published in every issue.
Helmed by longtime cartoon editor Bob Mankoff, the Tuesday ritual plays out much like open auditions for stage and screen, humanized by Mankoff’s predilection to be both mentor and psychoanalyst as well.
Mankoff, a prolific cartoonist in his own right (more than 900 of his cartoons have been published in The New Yorker since the 1970s), meets one-on-one with hopeful veteran and newbie New Yorker cartoonists and sifts through and comments upon their latest submissions. This process requires a thick skin, especially from newcomers, since Mankoff is not one to mince words…for better or worse. On a positive note, he also is quick to chuckle or laugh out loud and offer sincere encouragement and solid direction where needed.
Veteran New Yorker cartoonists still in play have a quick shot in Very Semi-Serious to fill in their back stories, including 89-year-old George Booth, Mort Gerberg and Roz Chast. The latter recalls her unlikely evolution as a cartoonist and equally uncomfortable introduction to The New Yorker’s male inner circle. There is a nod to the legendary talents of Charles Addams, William Steig, Peter Arno and James Thurber. And special focus is on the aspirations and psychological profiles of young people who show up week after week with new cartoons in hand and walk away with Bob Mankoff’s yea or nay.
Woven throughout Very Semi-Serious are personal vignettes profiling Mankoff himself. While these sequences would fit comfortably in a bio about Mankoff, they are off-point and distracting in this film.
Artists and illustrators, especially budding or established cartoonists, will find Very Semi-Serious to be especially informative and enlightening, as will avid fans of New Yorker cartoons in general. For those new to the magazine’s editorial or those fascinated by its history, more needed to be said in this film or needs to be said in subsequent films about the legendary cartoons and cartoonists who have graced and continue to grace its pages.
Very Semi-Serious…A Partially Thorough Portrait of New Yorker Cartoonists debuts on HBO tonight, Monday, December 14, 2015, 9:00 – 10:30 p.m. ET/PT. (Check listings for additional HBO playdates in the weeks ahead and availability on HBO NOW, HBO GO and HBO On Demand.) –Judith Trojan