My dad was a hard-core Lincoln buff. And, frankly, he didn’t have to work very hard to get me on board the Abraham Lincoln bandwagon. When Ken Burns’ groundbreaking miniseries, The Civil War, debuted on PBS, my dad and I shared that experience and every repeat broadcast thereafter. That I came to know Ken, during my professional career as a journalist and director of the Christopher Awards, was icing on the cake.
As I sat screening director Peter Kunhardt’s incredibly moving new documentary, Living with Lincoln, I especially missed my dad. He would have loved this film, and so, I hope, will you. It debuts on HBO, tonight, Monday, April 13, 2015, 9:00-10:15 p.m. ET/PT, on the eve of the 150th anniversary of Lincoln’s assassination. (Check HBO On Demand, and listings for additional HBO playdates in April.)
Yes, Living with Lincoln is a compelling look at Abraham Lincoln’s personal evolution as a man, father, husband and U.S. president. But it’s a story that could not have been fully told without the incredibly moving and complex thread that links Lincoln with five generations of one American family, the family of filmmaker Peter Kunhardt.
The story opens with the Civil War diary kept by battle-scarred Major William Neal Meserve. Determined to heal his father’s psyche and patch their painful father-son estrangement, William’s son, Frederick Hill Meserve, began collecting photographs and mementos relating to Abraham Lincoln and the Civil War to illustrate a book based on his dad’s diary. Abraham Lincoln was the first president to be photographed in office; but as Lincoln and the war faded from memory, the photos, glass negatives and presidential memorabilia were soon filed and forgotten in dusty attics, damp basements or obscure warehouse graveyards.
Frederick Hill Meserve’s quest to unearth and publish those photos (he privately published his first edition of The Photographs of Abraham Lincoln in 1911), became a lifelong passion that also involved the acquisition of rare books and all sorts of period ephemera relating to Lincoln. The project grew to encompass one of the largest private collections of 19th-century American photography, devoted primarily to Lincoln and the Civil War.
In short, the face we recognize on the U.S. penny, the five dollar bill and on the sculptures at Mount Rushmore and the Lincoln Memorial were made possible by Frederick Hill Meserve’s zeal to find, catalog and preserve images of Lincoln in period photographs.
But if you think the film, Living with Lincoln, is simply a documentary about collecting, preserving and storing documents, you’d be wrong. Not only was Meserve’s journey filled with fascinating twists and turns, but it tapped into familial compulsions and obsessions that pulled his daughter, her children and their children, for better or worse, into the mix and led to the making of this remarkable family film chronicle, directed, produced and narrated by Meserve’s great-grandson, Peter Kunhardt.
Seventy minutes fly by as Kunhardt explores the challenges faced by family members who were instrumental in the evolution of the Lincoln collection from its inception to the present-day. Lincoln’s historic narrative meshes with that of the filmmaker’s family–the former is richly evoked with vintage photos from the collection, the latter is beautifully illustrated with family photos, home movies and their ancestors’ own words (read in voice over by living relatives, which is a nice touch).
A sizable portion of the film focuses on the filmmaker’s grandmother, Frederick Meserve’s daughter Dorothy Meserve Kunhardt. Dorothy carried the burden of her father’s obsession throughout her storied but often difficult life. She was forever torn between her all-consuming dedication to her father’s Lincoln project and her much-needed income-producing career as a successful children’s book author and illustrator. The creation of her first best-selling book, Junket Is Nice, and her classic Pat the Bunny, the latter published by Random House in 1940, is a fascinating sidelight in this film.
Dorothy’s fertile creative mind was beset with depression, seemingly a family attribute, that was fueled by her struggle to fulfill all of the responsibilities she tackled as a devoted daughter, dedicated archivist, loving wife, mother, best-selling author and illustrator. She subsequently fell ill with lung disease, triggered by the hours she spent living and even sleeping amidst the dusty and moldy stacks of old books and ephemera she and her dad had collected.
Many of Dorothy’s projects fell by the wayside; but, aided by her son, Life magazine editor Philip B. Kunhardt, Jr., Dorothy Kunhardt’s own Lincoln book, Twenty Days, finally saw the light of day in 1965, inspired by the assassination of another American president, John F. Kennedy. Amazingly, I found a first edition of that book in my own dad’s Lincoln collection, and am thrilled to now know its provenance.
Awe-inspiring and poignant, Living with Lincoln moved me to tears. At its core, it’s a story about two American families and their resilience in the face of great challenges. It’s about their ability to silence naysayers and achieve monumental goals despite crippling emotional scars brought about by war, parental abandonment, financial ruin, debilitating illness, drug abuse, suicide and the death of one’s children. It’s about acknowledging the baggage and cherishing the personal best we carry from generation to generation in our own families and, most importantly, about the “better angels” among us who aspire to be good citizens, parents, children and, most of all, who remind us to remember, respect and treasure those who have made us proud to be Americans.
The Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library at Yale University has just purchased and will preserve the Meserve-Kunhardt Collection going forward. As reported in The New York Times on March 30, 2015, the collection now comprises “more than 73,000 items,” including “57,000 prints, as well as thousands of books, pamphlets, maps and theater broadsides.”
Abraham Lincoln was shot at Ford’s Theatre in Washington, D.C., on April 14, 1865. Be sure to watch Living with Lincoln, debuting tonight on the eve of the 150th anniversary of that tragedy, Monday, April 13, 2015, 9:00-10:15 p.m. ET/PT. (Check HBO On Demand, and listings for additional HBO playdates in April.)–Judith Trojan